2010
- Paul Secunda
2011
- Chad Emerson
2012
- Ben Barton
- Nancy Levit
- Ron Rychlak
2013
- Vince Cardi
2015
- Gail Richmond
2016
- Don Castleman
2017
- David Partlett
- Chris Pietruszkiewicz
2018
- Robert Felix
- Paul Kurtz
- Ellen Podgor
2019
- Shakira Pleasant
2020
- Tom Metzloff
- Caprice Roberts
2022
Recognized as members of the Mentor Committee:
- Jasmine Abdel-Khalik (co-chair)
- Catherine Hancock (co-chair)
- Cynthia Alkon
- Todd Berger
- Teneille Brown
- Donald Campbell
- Katerina Lewinbuk
- Suparna Malempati
- Marc Roark